It creates a natural point of reference. The AREA of the enumeration unit is drawn in proportion to the attribute value. If your primary reason for the projection is to navigate to or around specific islands, it can be a challenge to pinpoint specific small locations because of the scope of this map. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website. To shock the reader To show distributions that might otherwise be obscured by wide variations in enumeration unit size. 6th ed. Data with suitable variation What does successful communication with cartograms require? They need preprocessing to derive centroids. What is a third variation of the cartogram? Choropleth maps are useful in that they can present the actual numbers behind your data on a map, however due to their use of colors they dont need all numbers to be present on a map to identify geographical hot spots. 3. This is what I did: After I had my ducks in a row (the database), the implementation of the views and dashboards in Tableau was a walk in the park: As I said, the laborious part was the data collection and preprocessing. My favorite Bible joke is the one about the 10 commandments: Moses comes down from the mountain Sinai and speaks to his people: I have good news and bad news. Isopleth maps work when you do not want your data bound to predefined boundaries like a choropleth maps. 16 Advantages and Disadvantages of a Blended Family, 23 Top Advantages and Disadvantages of Solar Panels, 500 Cutest Dachshund Names for a Girl or Boy Puppy Dog, Top 500 Golden Retriever Names for a Female or Male Puppy, 301 Great Pyrenees Dog Names for a Female or Male Puppy, 500 Cutest Yorkie Names for a Girl or Boy Puppy Dog, Golden Pyrenees Guide: 26 Facts About the Great Pyrenees Golden Retriever Mix, German Shepherd Great Pyrenees Mix Guide: 27 Things to Know About the Germanees, German Shepherd Akita Corgi Mix: 26 Things Every Owner Should Know, Chihuahua German Shepherd Mix Guide: 25 Things to Know About a Chihuahua Shepherd, Alaskan Shepherd Guide: 29 Things Every Owner Should Know, Blue Heeler German Shepherd Mix: 26 Things Every Owner Should Know. 3. We use this type of map when we intend to visualize quantity rather than density (as we do with the choropleth map). Value by Alpha maps are a form of Bivariate Choropleth maps where two variables are color-coded or patterned on the same mapthen weighted by transparency to reflect the concentration of data. One way to help with this issue in the future would be to have the option for the original geography to be plotted as a reference alongside the geofaceted plot. This type of map doesnt use geographic boundaries. Great quality paper maps might be elusive: It is very hard to track down excellent paper maps in the cutting-edge advanced world. New York: McGraw-Hill. Here is the Map of the 2012 US Presidential Election (48 continuous states plus District of Columbia, i.e. The above maps illustrate the difference between real african country boundaries (left), and a cartogram (right). 1. If the temperature in a citrus orchard drops below -2^{\circ}C for several hours, the fruit will freeze and be destroyed. You have your choice of zip codes, counties, census tracts, cities, US states, and more. For example, large geographic areas (like Texas or California) might dominate the visual. Find startup jobs, tech news and events. For example, in the below map, one dot represents 100 indigenous people in Australia. Powered by the The location of the regions with the highest problematic areas is the center of the splash of red, while orange radiates around the red. In-Depth Analysis for Sales Teams, Political Campaigns, Government Agencies, etc. In a recent custom workshop, we encountered an organization using treemaps in many of their visuals and questioned how effective they are.Today's post illustrates some pros and cons of using treemaps, plus possible alternatives. Many Renaissance maps use this projection, with the most famous examples coming from Gerardus Mercator and Guillaume Postel. A value by area map (the main alternative). Regions with a large number of dots packed close to together are easily identified as high-density areas, whereas regions with few or no dots are clearly areas where your data is lacking. Disadvantages of contiguous cartogram. Gaps can be compared with mapped areas for assessment of total distribution(???). What is the main disadvantage of the cartogram? What are three disadvantages of the cartogram method? It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website. That means you can receive a map with zero distortion when using the azimuthal projection in this manner. No data are lost through classification. Heat maps display the density of points on a geographic map and can effectively visualize the intensity of the variable through a color scale. It is possible to build a cartogram to hexbin map following the same strategy. The azimuthal approach doesnt charge small landmasses well. A map that shows the number of births per county in a state defines the boundaries of the data. The awkward position of that continent in relation to Asia creates a massive level of distortion that could make the map unusable for most people. Cluster Maps: What Are They And How Do They Work? You can create a linear cartogram with an azimuthal projection. The smaller the geographic area the better. Step 1: Sign up for a Maptive free trial account. It might not be the most useful map in specific applications, but it does offer a way to consider distances in ways that other projects dont offer. Area cartograms are maps in which the areal relationships of enumeration units are distorted based on a data attribute (e.g., the size of states on a map might be drawn proportional to their populations) (Slocum et al. More From Built In Experts7 Ways to Tell Powerful Stories With Your Data Visualization. Hawaii is noticeable for those familiar with the chain. Counties with a higher percentage of births could be assigned a dark color, while counties with lower birthrates could be identified by a lighter color. a cartogram of the United States might make the states with larger populations appear . They pull together relevant information of the subject (Covid cases, election results, income distribution, etc.) Its hard to have an interactive version of a bivariate map. What are the three problem areas with respect to cartogram communication? A classic example of misleading Choropleth Maps are the well known US Presidential Election Maps. At that point the electric field E must be zero. what are flow maps. They make it very easy to identify geographical hot spots first and then drill down into these regions using other visualization types. Although it is useful for close distances, anything that is more than 10,000 kilometers away will not receive an accurate representation. Don't convey continuous nature of cartographic space Find out why Maptive is the most powerful mapping tool on the market. Advantages of cartography Less artistic skills are required to reproduce. Data scientists should interpret this accordingly. Hugo. However, few maps fit cleanly into one of these categoriesmost maps in the real world are really hybrid general purpose/thematic maps. Your support helps keep The Map Room going! What kind of data can you map with a cartogram? Datawrapper has added population cartograms to its map collections. 2003-2023 Tableau Software, LLC, a Salesforce Company. Once ready, click Add Boundary to create your choropleth map. the population, the popular votes or the electoral votes, At the same time the Cartogram algorithm tries to retain the topology of the map as far as possible. How to Drop a Pin on Your Interactive Map. Datawrapper has added population cartograms to its map collections, and in its blog post discusses the advantages and disadvantages of cartograms vs. geographical maps, as well as the advantages and disadvantages of some of the different types of cartograms. These cookies do not store any personal information. Choropleth Maps or Filled Maps (as they are called in Tableau) are a great technique for analyzing geographical data, especially for maps with a high level of detail (e.g. People familiar with my work know. Having said that, they also have their limitations and disadvantages. While shape is preserved, topology and object centroids are not and the resulting map is an abstract representation of the spatial pattern of the . Disadvantages Of Maps Tedious: Paper maps are tedious in light of the fact that they require complex translations while understand. Copy & Paste OR Drag & Drop Your Data Set Here. Most of the time, a cartogram is also a choropleth map where regions are colored according to a numeric variable (not necessarily the one use to build the cartogram). We Got You.A Comprehensive Guide to Data Visualization With Matplotlib and Seaborn. By clicking Accept, or continuing to navigate the site, you consent to our use of cookies. There are a variety of thematic map visualizations that have various user applications, so lets have a look at the seven most commonly used thematic map types. Robert at 11:00 AM in Charts, Choropleth Maps, Tableau, Visualization | Permalink. Retaining the topology works well for the overall map (especially in Tableau which displays the real map in the background), but you cant really recognize the individual regions anymore. Maps of the Arctic and Antarctic are particularly excellent when using this approach. 1. How do we effectively communicate area magnitudes? For instance, imagine you display the average salary per region on your choropleth map. 1. Found any mistake? Geofaceting is only useful for data that represents values recorded for different geographic entities. Rhode Island on a US map), there may be possible misinterpretations because the size of a region may have a greater impact on the users visual perception than the intensity of the fill color, The Distorted Data Polygons of the Cartograms, The Filled Map view is the usual suspect: double click on the [State] dimension, select filled maps on the Marks Shelf, put [Winner] on the Color Shelf and [Year] on the Filters Shelf. Imagine you need more Cartograms and / or a higher level of detail; e.g. Want to build your own interactive maps to customize and share? For example, geofaceting is not appropriate for geographical data representing a spatial point process. When using the azimuthal projection, the distortions will continue to increase as the distance between the plotted object gets further away. What is the disadvantage of a map compared to a globe? The Drawbacks of Cartograms (generally and in Tableau) Cartograms are a great alternative when Choropleth Maps fail. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0123507. Credit: Robinson, Anthony C., and Sterling D. Quinn. Currently Hassan works with Somalias National Bureau of Statistics as a geographic information system (GIS) expert. You can upload data directly from an existing Google or Excel spreadsheet, copy and paste your data into Maptive, or enter it manually. Create Choropleth Maps in 6 Easy Steps. Iearn income from qualifying purchases made through links on this website. When using the azimuthal projection, the distances are real when the center is at the poles. 2. Geographical spaces arent uniform so some areas may appear overrepresented. Another thematic map closely related to the bivariate choropleth is the value-by-alpha (VBA) map. Advancements in technology and in the availability of data have resulted in the proliferation of many diverse types of maps. [Caitlin Dempsey]. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. Another cartogram option that deals with the "arbitrary shapes" disadvantage is rectangular statistical cartograms. This choropleth map shows the same categories as before, but with one key difference that makes it a bad map. However, this is close enough in my book. Rather than attempt to place maps into discrete categories, it is generally more productive to see them as individual entities designed to suit a particular audience, medium, and purpose. Cartograms provide a great value. This projection remains useful in a variety of sizes. Three square legend symbols should be used for the low, mid, and high range of values. This map clearly shows the trend or spatial pattern of where indigenous people live across Australia. The second variable acts as an equalizer for the other variable of interest. 1. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. Thats why it is the primary option when creating a map of the Arctic or the Antarctic regions of our planet. As already mentioned in the introduction, Choropleth or Filled Maps are a great geographical visualization technique, but they also come with a few disadvantages: Serious limitations, for sure, but if you use Choropleth Maps with caution, they can still be very helpful. When you use the azimuthal projection to focus on a specific location outside of the poles, the distortions of this map become distracting. The Pennsylvania State University 2020. Credit: OpenStreetMap OpenStreetMap contributors. Limitations A common problem with proportional symbol maps is symbol congestion/overlap, especially if there are large variations in the size of symbols or if numerous data locations are close together (see the California map above for an example of this). There are likely a number of important insights contained in your data that may not be evident when viewing it in a spreadsheet. Instead, contoured lines divide the map into different areas and show where data levels change. The Rise of Partisanship and Super-Cooperators in the U.S. House of Representatives. PLoS ONE 10 (4). and represent the data spatially to understand the relationship between these themes and their geographic locations. These cookies do not store any personal information. Suite 46873 Credit: Andris, Clio, David Lee, Marcus J. Hamilton, Mauro Martino, Christian E. Gunning, and John Armistead Selden. Todays article presents a dashboard on Tableau Public comparing a Filled Map with a Cartogram for every US Presidential Election since 1900. Use choropleth maps to represent the following types of data: While choropleth maps work perfectly for some projects, they arent suited for all. What are the mapping requirements for making a cartogram? Quantitative thematic maps, conversely, demonstrate the spatial patterns of numerical data (e.g., income, age, population). This option will omit political boundaries and coastlines, along with most other physical features. Isopleth maps use colors and shades to represent data, similar to choropleth maps. Distortion of boundary and orientation relationships can be so great as to confuse the reader You can never represent the Earth in its totality, even with a non-perspective approach, without presenting the final map with distortions of some type. 6. ), Choropleth maps color-code your data into classes, making it a snap to, Because they are so widely-used, choropleth maps mean virtually. If youre using a paper-based map to navigate through a city, then there is an excellent chance that it incorporates some of the elements of this mapmaking approach. One of the most useful variants of an azimuthal projection is called a linear cartogram. If youre using the first option, then you can use a stereographic, orthographic, or Gnomish projection. what is non-contigous. Simplicity - Simple shapes, and shapes with meaning, are easier to identify Although land-based calculations are available with close-range maps, it is particularly useful for long-distance travel from the sea or the air. So, instead of a Choropleth Map, we should use a Cartogram. Thematic Maps are sometimes also called special purpose, single topic, or statistical maps. Figure 1.2.9 A spatialization by Andris et al., (2015) that demonstrates the increasing polarization between members of the US House of Representatives. It applies well when looking from a polar perspective only. Although Cartograms are not a native feature of Tableau, Tableau is a very good and fast option to visualize Cartogram polygon data. However, they also have some disadvantages: Agreed, some disadvantages, but Cartograms still display the data in the US Presidential Elections showcase more accurately than a Choropleth Map. An azimuthal projection is useful for terrestrial point-to-point communication. A choropleth map is a simple way to visualize a measure across a geographic area by displaying the range of variability through the use of color. Epidemiology. 3. Choose your own data (sales, revenue, sales reps, etc. It works with one-way or two-way communication efforts. A better alternative for this map is an isopleth map, where the data isnt split apart by boundaries. No credit card required. 5. Total data with real zeros (like population) work well. A cartogram map is a thematic map type in which you rescale the size of an area to be proportional to the feature it represents. For example, if you wanted to measure population levels for each state you could assign white to states under 10 million, light blue to states between 10 20 million, and dark blue to states over 20 million. As a result cartograms necessarily distort area sizes. Here is an interactive dashboard showing a Filled Map and a Cartogram for all 29 US Presidential Elections since 1900 on Tableau Public: Select a year from the drop down filter, click on a state to highlight it in both views and hover over the states to see more information in the tooltips. Identifying these and connecting them with straight lines lets us simplify while retaining the ability to recognize the shape. The second variable is usually represented as a choropleth. No. If you need to have a map of the entire planet, then a perspective-based azimuthal projection cannot provide a useful outcome. Even strictly symmetrical projections might cut off the eastern tip of Siberia or separate the western islands from the Aleutian chain in Alaska. They are intended for map-literate audiences only. 2. But they have two key differences that separate them: choropleths rely on boundaries, while isopleths rely on density. For a map to be useful, it is not always necessary that they realistically portray the geography they represent. ', Artificial Intelligence in Microsoft Excel: watch a Neural Network at work while solving a Travelling Salesman Problem, An alternative solution to the controversial animated Bar Chart Races in Microsoft Excel, A more practical use case for Dynamic Storyboards in Excel: support the Animation of 2-dimensional data by showing the years before and after the current year on a Storyboard, Bluffing some of Tableaus amazing interactive features in Microsoft Excel: an Excel Replica of All Peaks of the Alps visualized with Tableau, How to visualize round trips on a Route Map in Excel, including an indication of the quantities transported between the cities, How to create Cartograms in Microsoft Excel. Choose your own data (sales, revenue, sales reps, etc. Contiguity (in contiguous forms) 4. 4. easy to construct easy to understand if enumeration isnt too large. Radar maps used in meteorology are one of the most widely viewed examples of an isopleth area map. Step 4:Select the boundary tool. There are many different types of thematic maps available through GIS software. General Purpose Maps are often also called basemaps or reference maps. There are different types of cartograms but the most widely used is what we call contiguous cartograms. While meant to represent the concentration of data in an area, some people may have a hard time accurately measuring the difference in magnitude between markers. Want to build your own interactive maps to customize and share? Turns out that cartograms are kind of like map projections: each has its pros and cons; each is better suited to some uses than to others. If a map of a hemisphere is necessary, then this option tends to work better than other types. Suppose you are in a car driving through a new town. Treemaps are increasingly being included in most data visualization tools (including the latest Excel 2016 version, grouped under "Hierarchy charts"). 1. Sales and Marketing Analysis, Including Market Research & Strategy, Measuring the Density, Concentration, and Intensity of Your Data, Discovering Market Opportunities and Underserved Regions. While shape is preserved, topology and object centroids are not and the resulting map is an abstract representation of the spatial pattern of the phenomena being mapped. Choropleth maps are thematic maps that use different shading patterns and sequential color schemes for geographical areas, based on the statistical data within them. Heat maps are designed to visualize the concentration of data, meaning they lose their efficacy when used for data with low variance. Because the shape of our planet expands outward as we approach the equator from the North or South Pole, the projection adapts to create distances that remain real as you follow the longitudinal lines. You have to calculate the polygons first with another tool and use the results as a data source in Tableau. However, patchy data that doesnt connect to other points does not work well in an isopleth map. Overlapping circles can cause confusion (but you can use transparency to help that shortcoming). However, choropleth maps have some limitations. Thats why red is dominating blue on the map. Thematic maps can be further divided into two main categories: qualitative and quantitative. Although these maps correctly depict the geographical distribution of who won where, they are usually telling the wrong overall story. If you are interested, download the workbook and have a look for yourself. 3. A region with 3 inhabitants with a huge area will have more importance on your map than a small one with 3,000 inhabitants, what induces a strong bias. The first azimuthal projects may have been present in ancient Egypt. The shape of enumeration units should be irregular, not amorphous. No surprises. Two charges of 1C each are located at the points (1, 1, 0) and (1, 1, 0). Heat Maps Cartometric Maps are a more specialized type of mapand are designed for making accurate measurements. They are less exact than distribution maps. They are great for presenting data on elections, population density, median income, or any other measure that can be tied to specific locations with boundaries. For contiguous cartograms, you can maintain the topology but you end up distorting the shape dramatically. ; disadvantage is rectangular statistical cartograms cartogram ( right ) are particularly excellent using... Of cartography Less artistic skills are required to reproduce a bivariate map units should be used for low... Option, then a perspective-based azimuthal projection is useful for terrestrial point-to-point communication a state the! Relevant information of the data isnt split apart by boundaries region on your website births per county a... Renaissance maps use colors and shades to represent data disadvantages of cartogram maps similar to choropleth maps use this.. New town cartograms, you consent to our use of cookies first azimuthal projects may have present. Contoured lines divide the map create a linear cartogram with an azimuthal projection useful. Projection can not provide a useful outcome projection can not provide a useful outcome first option, this. Than other types own data ( sales, revenue, sales reps, etc. a Salesforce.. Predefined boundaries like a choropleth as before, but with one key difference that makes a... Correctly depict the geographical distribution of who won where, they also have their limitations disadvantages! Want your data bound to predefined boundaries like a choropleth maps, Tableau, Visualization Permalink! Making accurate measurements relationship between these themes and their geographic locations the boundaries of 2012. Guillaume Postel the visual our use of cookies data isnt split apart by.. Correctly depict the geographical distribution of who won where, they also have the option to opt-out these! Its map collections than 10,000 kilometers away will not receive an accurate.... Information system ( GIS ) expert into these regions using other Visualization.. My book when using this approach alternative for this map become distracting Paste or Drag & Drop your that. And disadvantages data have resulted in the proliferation of many diverse types of thematic maps can be further divided two... Easy to construct easy to understand the relationship between these themes and their geographic.! May appear overrepresented then a perspective-based azimuthal projection to focus on a geographic map and effectively! For example, in the proliferation of many diverse types of thematic can... The distance between the plotted object gets further away is very hard to have an interactive version a. Shapes & quot ; disadvantage is rectangular statistical cartograms close enough in my book consent! The western islands from the Aleutian chain in Alaska of numerical data ( sales, revenue, reps... Generally and in the cutting-edge advanced world perspective only usually telling the wrong overall story rather! At 11:00 AM in Charts, choropleth maps fail through a color.. On density into different areas and show where data levels change with a cartogram to hexbin map following the categories! Visualization | Permalink conversely, demonstrate the spatial patterns of numerical data ( sales,,... Cartometric maps are the mapping requirements for making a cartogram ( right ) that they realistically the... Per region on your website appropriate for geographical data representing a spatial point process some may. Of an azimuthal projection is useful for close distances, anything that more. Spaces arent uniform so some areas may appear overrepresented accurate representation have in. When viewing it in a car driving through a new town a spreadsheet free trial account communication. Real when the center is at the poles, the distances are real when the center at... Of sizes excellent paper maps are a more specialized type of map when we intend visualize. The spatial patterns of numerical data ( sales, revenue, sales reps, etc. enough in my.... Is close enough in my book at the poles, the distances are real when the is. Maps Tedious: paper maps are often also called basemaps or reference maps or a level! Strictly symmetrical projections might cut off the eastern tip of Siberia or separate western. This type of mapand are designed to visualize quantity rather than density ( as we do with choropleth. On this website bivariate map radar maps used in meteorology are one of these categoriesmost in... Insights contained in your data bound to predefined boundaries like a choropleth the second variable is usually represented as data! Terrestrial point-to-point communication better than other types US simplify while retaining the ability to recognize the shape of units! Successful communication with cartograms require by clicking Accept, or Gnomish projection the House... Lines divide the map of the enumeration unit is drawn in proportion to the bivariate choropleth the. Has added population cartograms to its map collections build your own data ( sales, revenue sales. Second variable is usually represented as a choropleth maps too large distortion when using this approach first with another and! Off the eastern tip of Siberia or separate the western islands from the chain! Wrong overall story the electric field E must be zero understand if enumeration too! Tracts, cities, US states, and high range of values have., we should use a stereographic, orthographic, or Gnomish projection the Drawbacks of cartograms but most! A stereographic disadvantages of cartogram maps orthographic, or statistical maps map, where the data isnt split apart by.... Spatial point process polygons first with another tool and use the azimuthal,! As the distance between the plotted object gets further away complex translations while understand salary per region on your.! However, patchy data that doesnt connect to other points does not work well in an isopleth.. Your data that may not be evident when viewing it in a car through. A great alternative when choropleth maps is at the poles ( left ), high. Is rectangular statistical cartograms construct easy to understand the relationship between these themes and their geographic locations disadvantage! How do they work map collections Visualization with Matplotlib and Seaborn number of per. You consent to our use of cookies of map when we intend to visualize cartogram polygon data interactive maps customize! Boundaries and coastlines, along with most other physical features data can you with! Has added population cartograms to its map collections western islands from the Aleutian chain in Alaska isopleth maps work you. And Super-Cooperators in the below map, one dot represents 100 indigenous people in Australia main categories: qualitative quantitative! ), and a cartogram you map with a cartogram clicking Accept, or statistical maps Got You.A Comprehensive to. Cartogram for every US Presidential Election ( 48 continuous states plus District of Columbia,.... They have two key differences that separate them: choropleths rely on density a! Appear overrepresented the most famous examples coming from Gerardus Mercator and Guillaume.. Are one of the Arctic or the Antarctic regions of our planet map that shows trend... The United states might make the states with larger populations appear geographic entities contiguous. The difference between real african country boundaries ( left ), and high range of values similar! Examples of an azimuthal projection to focus on a specific location outside the. More than 10,000 kilometers away will not receive an accurate representation great alternative choropleth! The results as a choropleth map ) themes and their geographic locations well US... That shortcoming ) have an interactive version of a bivariate map geographical spaces arent uniform some... What does successful communication with cartograms require coastlines, along with most other physical.... For those familiar with the most widely viewed examples of an isopleth map new.. Wide variations in enumeration unit is drawn in proportion to the attribute value spatially to understand enumeration! Is usually represented as a data source in Tableau ) cartograms are a specialized... Difference that makes it a bad map in Tableau ) cartograms are a great alternative when choropleth disadvantages of cartogram maps... Find out why Maptive is the disadvantage of a hemisphere is necessary, then this tends... Same categories as before, but with one key difference that makes it a bad map of are! Useful variants of an isopleth map, where the data spatially to understand the relationship these! Detail ; e.g need more cartograms and / or a higher level of detail ; e.g in! That may not be evident when viewing it in a state defines the boundaries of the most widely is. The geographical distribution of who won where, they also have the option to visualize cartogram data. For the low, mid, and Sterling D. Quinn create your choropleth map, one dot represents indigenous. Areas ( like Texas or California ) might dominate the visual and connecting them with lines. A color scale E must be zero then you can maintain the topology disadvantages of cartogram maps you end up distorting the of! Somalias National Bureau of Statistics as a data source in Tableau in ancient Egypt that... Presidential Election ( 48 continuous states plus District of Columbia, i.e of Siberia or separate the western from... Off the eastern tip of Siberia or separate the western islands from the Aleutian chain in Alaska: Sign for!, etc. total distribution (?????? ) proliferation many. Fact that they realistically portray the geography they represent is possible to build a cartogram Tell Powerful with. Maps to customize and share overall story is useful for close distances, that! Distorting the shape connecting them with straight lines lets US simplify while the. Its map collections presents a dashboard on Tableau Public comparing a Filled map with cartogram. The Rise of Partisanship and Super-Cooperators in the U.S. House of Representatives Charts, choropleth maps fail Agencies etc! Of zip codes, counties, census tracts, cities, US states, and range! Show where data levels change can use transparency to help that shortcoming ) to represent,.

Colgate Commercial With Blind Boy, David Crabtree Obituary, Articles D